Thank you all so much for hearing me out. I emailed the person and let her know, very nicely, that I was more than unhappy about the matter. She is a widowed woman who makes her living this way. She researched it and found it was legal. So she picks what she feels will be good sellers and puts them up on Ebay. This one did say, in very small print, that my son didn't even notice, the pattern was from a magazine. However, reading it that way, I still would not have made the connection that it was 3 pages torn from a magazine. She was kind and I am now educated.