Okay, so you're human like the rest of us. Happens a lot...and I am not gonna fess up either. I'd have shared it with SIL and dumped some ice cream on top and liked it, I'll bet it was good.
Sounds like the time I got mad at my son's Boy Scout group who were having a party in our back yard and making home made ice cream in a crank-it container. They were playing keep away with boxes of red hots, sprinkling them all over the place. So I took them away from one smart mouthed brat (not saying who, but he has my DNA) and in anger tossed 6 or 8 whole boxes of redhots in the vanilla ice cream and then insisted they eat it. Turns out everyone loved it!!! Even me..sigh.