My baby blanket was tied - that's all my gma ever did. It wore out everywhere else (mainly the edges and corners) and the ties were still fine so I guess it all depends on the use. Mine went through a LOT and wasn't officially retired until I was in HS and it just started deteriorating. I made one for DH 7 or 8 years ago that was tied and it's still going strong. I am getting ready to make a king and will most likely tie it b/c I am going to slowly hand quilt our "story" into it. It's also good for some kids, like mine, who will play with the ties as they fall asleep. A lot of it is personal preference.