Okay, I will play too!
I hate to touch rubber bands because of the smell it leaves, but I am not creeped out by them.
I do not like the feel of styrofoam or wool. Can't hardly stand the smell of burned popcorn or hard boiled eggs. Very sensitive nose: I can smell skunk 20 minutes before anyone else can. Also, I can't stand the sound of a metal pot rubbing in the enamel sink bottom.
As far as being creeped out, cockroaches are at the top, I think. Also looking down from a high spot, like in a high rise or at a gorge is not fun.
If you run a daycare for 6 years by yourself, you will get over a lot of creeps in the bodily fluids department real quick.