I looked,but i don't like either one.It might be the same ,BUT their still different.Why,#1 metal tape wasn't rounded at the corners.#2 outer fabric is fine but i have a inside fabric a linning i guess.that's longer and folds over from inside out.You have a 1/4 inch you fold under and sew down.That's where you put the metal tape.I still like the pattern better.I like my Snap Bags neat,those were not.Sorry if i like something i stick with it.You could put in a zipper not the metal tape.