I tend to do the same thing. I make sqeaky toys that get the squeek chewed out of them in 2.5 seconds. I just pick up the stuffing and put it back in add a new sqeak and wait to do it again. I bought a bag of squeakers somewhere on the net. The funny part was Odie the Pug found my stash one day and hid about 20 of them all over the house. He thought he was something! =)