Just a reminder, this exchange is for 5 fat quarters in Valentine colors or themes, reds, pinks, red and white etc. There is no gift stipulated, if you want to put a few chocolates in, that is fine, but it is not a requirement. It's a fat quarter exchange to brighten up the dull long days of winter. :)
The Secret Santa is something special and that is why a gift is included in it. If we do that for every exchange, then SS loses it's special quality and just becomes another exchange.
S.D.