Originally Posted by KiwiQuilter
Oh I just knew it would end in tears.
As others have suggested... I would patch it up as best as you can.
A dog will know if you get a replacement. Sometimes they won't even be bothered with the new one - different smells, etc.
The more I think about these comments I do believe you are right. What do you think of my getting another duck and replaceing the inside stuffing with the old duck (at least some of it) do you think there will be enough scent to over ride the new scent?