Be sure to check out Lolly's basement shop. They have a boat down there filled to the brim with fat quarters. I LOVE going through there. I only get to Shipshewana once or twice a year, but never leave Lolly's with less than 100 fat quarters from the boat. All the fabric in the basement shop is discounted too. I'm thinking it's discontinued fabric.
I also love Yoder's Department store in Shipshewana. They have a very nice selection of fabric and patterns.
Have fun! I'm going the end of May for a wedding and can't wait to shop. My cousin lives in Goshen.