Definitely the New York Beauty, it would be stunning and it would work really well with the colours to create a fabulous sunset effect. I presume you'll be using a mix of fabrics, not just one of each? So that you could have bits of red in the fabrics, for instance (I tend to think in batiks) which would help pull the whole thing together.
If you do end up using white in the quilt, don't forget to prewash your fabrics, otherwise those purples and oranges will probably wreck the white the first time the quilt is washed.