I have given up on using tubs; I like the plastic shelves, the big ones, on rollers (Target usually has them). Label the outside with a color or however works for you. This way the shelves can be rolled anywhere, so my family isn't overwhelmed by tubs that are difficult to move. As for the S&P shakers, I'm starting to downsize my less beloved rubber stamps. Either pack some away or sell your less special ones on Etsy. Aren't we lucky to have so much stuff!!!
Hugs,
Helen