I like your location listing: "middle of nowhere" - I grew up in just east of Kokomo, which pretty much describes it. I have been quilting almost 20 years and I live in Milwaukee now. I would start with a sampler, or a simple quilt block like churn dash. Figure the final size of your quilt, then divide by the size block you want. I suggest 12" finished to start. From this math, you can figure a setting (5 across by 4 down etc). Add border - 1/3 size of block (4" border) is a good default...or make it how you like. If you are near Kokomo, I am coming home for Easter for a week, and you are welcome to PM me today for my phone number. I can pass on the name of some quilters, shopping etc in central Indiana.
Piece. :lol: