I use crushed walnuts which are sold in pet stores as litter/bedding. Here are a few of the pin cushions we made recently at a quilting retreat. My friends keep trying to get me to do projects out of my comfort zone. I think it might be working :-)
Chicky pin cushion
[ATTACH=CONFIG]202484[/ATTACH]
Stacked flowers pin cushion
[ATTACH=CONFIG]202485[/ATTACH]
Four patch pin cushion - looks like a tooth to me
[ATTACH=CONFIG]202486[/ATTACH]