Oh Barb...you are such a quick fixer, I love your ideas!! :D
I have been to the quilting class today and asked a few opinions there too, so now I have even more ideas to mull over tee hee!!
Think this is was I will do...
1. Chop the outside border down the middle
2. Add a small plain border (No idea what just yet, will have to see what I have got left.)
3. Chop up the remaining half border width ways and make a scrappy piano style border about 3" wide using up some of the scraps left over and the fabric for the binding I reserved.
4. Add binding to match thin border.
Now does that sound like a decent plan? :D