you made a wonderful quilt, but, as you said it was for "the daughter of my daughter's SIL" - maybe the other one was made by the MIL of the girl, or sister or someone they sort of had to oooh over - family politics lol share
oh, also, did you put a label on it, like, "lovingly handmade for the little blessing by-" ??? labels are a must for gifts. even if the recipient doesnt have sense of value, maybe others looking at it will