Paul Newman is my choice. Those blue eyes did it every time. I actually saw him locally when they were filming Empire Falls here in Maine. I was driving near where the movie trailers were and this old, scruffy man walked right in front of my car, I almost hit him. Much to my surprise when I viewed the film months later, the old, scruffy guy was in character and WAS Paul Newman. I had stalked the filming sites for weeks trying to get a peek at him and didn't even recognize him when he walked in front of me. Who knew he had aged?