Originally Posted by auntdeb
I actually like the pinwheels on just the three sides. I tend to like asymetrical stuff but I think the second way is very cute.
Does your friend like symetrical or asymetrical designs? I much prefer the latter, but have friends who must have total sameness all around.
To me your pinwheels are the perfect size to add movement and life to the design when used with restraint, such as only at top and bottom, or on three sides with a solid or floral or nothing on the other side. I think the four added tigers detract from the center panel, and make the design cutesy instead of striking, which is fine if that's what you're striving for, just not as interesting or unique. I would use the extra pinwheels and the tigers on the back, for a reversible quilt, and add your choice of borders to one of the two layouts you had going originally. Your design sense is excellent, so go with your instincts and your friend's tastes.