I like the first one better. You might feel differently once you add a couple of borders to it. That can make all the difference in the world. I just finished a top that I felt the same way about. I thought the one I did was very blah (it was a kit). I had extra from the back, so I added that as borders and it does make a big difference. Maybe if you lay some fabrics out with it you will feel differently. If not, put it aside and go back to it another day. You can always donate it if you still don't like it.