I am going through the same thing. The lady at the LQS helped me pick out the fabric and I loved it while I was cutting it out. It is supposed to be a Christmas present for my DMIL. But now that I have 3 of the blocks finished, I am doubting that the colors coordinate at all!
I looked at your pics - I think it will make a pretty quilt! I do like the second one best, though. Let us know what you decide to do! Good luck!