I would want to know where it is going. By that I mean the color scheme of the room and accessories [chair covers, drapes/curtains/blinds, rug and more], and even the dishes you are going to use.
I love them all. Yes, the second red speaks to me more. but I'm not you. Again, if you are going to put a centerpiece on this then I might just change my vote.
Personal choice is just that.
ali