That is the prices at our LQS as well. I usually try to wait until she has a sale, 2 a year, unless I really need a fabric fix. LOL
I would rather buy less fabric but quality fabric than have a bunch of cheaper fabric. As you said 'you get what you pay for'
I have been purchasing fabric from Erica's the last couple months. They have LQS quality fabric, same price as the LQS, but they have End of Bolt Sale fabric, the fabric is marked down 40%. Its divided into color catagories, some weeks they have more fabric than others. Just keep checking everyday. Check the website you may find something you like. I've never ordered any more than 5 yards at a time and postage was $5.99. Happy Qulting/Shopping :D