I think what we refer to as "quilting fabric" is generally just 100% cotton fabric. It is predictable in its use and in handling. Rotary cutting is so popular because a lot of patterns are made by cutting strips, sewing the strips together and sub-cutting into smaller bits. I can't even imagine going back to using scissors. Do you know what your problem with the cutter is? Was your blade dull? Did you not apply enough pressure? Was your fabric too thick (or slick)? Did you hold the cutter at a different angle (needs to be 90 degrees to the ruler)? Just hang in there. With the help here you'll be an expert in no time.