Since I am a newbie, and I learn way more by seeing rather than reading, I did join. I think being able to watch the videos has helped me quite a bite. Depending on how much you shop at Joann's, it can definitely pay for the cost of membership in what you save at Joann's. You also save 10% on all orders from Keepsake Quilting, if you shop there. Different people have different views; but I for one am glad I joined. I don't know that I will renew next year, but for sure this year; it's definitely helped this newbie.