Some of my favorite quilts are antique and vintage ones that are made "scrappy".. using whatever came to hand when the quilter was making it. I love the primitive appearance they produced.. My own quilts are boring compared to those! But really, whether a quilt is scrappy, wonky, or controlled piecing doesn't matter a bit to me. It's the final result that either makes my heart beat faster or I just shrug and move on to the next one.. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder... and thank goodness for that!