It definitely isn't the most beautiful quilt I have ever seen. I'm sorry to have to say but I really don't care for this quilt. I like the pattern, but it is hidden with this particular group of fabrics. I don't think I could have figured a way to put all of those fabs together to look like anything resembling a quilt. You did well. Seems like you must have passed the test. I do hope your friend appreciates all of your time and effort and never puts you through a test like this again.