A half dollar in the toe then a piece if fruit a coloring book (roll it) box crayons, a little matchbox car or a pretty little bracelet, a big gum ball(one of those fancy ones you get in a machine),, a small hand held game ( tilt games are fun and fit in a stocking) and of course a candy cane, Add a noise maker to be used at New Years,a small sketch pad /note pad, nail polish,Boy Scout knife, lip stick (light pink that tasted like strawberries) Penciles with a name on them,perfume (lilly of the Vally was my first)a rolled pair of scocks (fun ones with different color toes)
I use to love to come up with ideas when the kids were small.It was so much fun. Hope all these help. Sure once you get started you will get your own ideas.