shelby sounds like he has some separation anxiety. if you p.m. me your address i will gladly send you this babble ball that is supposed to keep dogs occupied for hours/days/weeks/ the rest of his life!! anyway, no one told my ladies that they are dogs (say WHAT???) so they just look at it with disdain. i know they would love for your puppy to have it, and it's very durable. trust me it's like brand new. it's yours for free if you give me your address.