Older eyes don't pick out patterns as easily as younger ones do. I am an NP, and I've worked a lot with the elderly. I would say either pattern would be fine, the second might stand out more -- or perhaps not depending how how good his eyesight is. The colors are very calming, and a lovely selection for an elderly man. You've done a great job! If he doesn't like it, I'll take the quilt! LOL!