Former Wmsburg resident here......the one at W. Francis Street is a finished quilt store, among other gifts and things.....probably not what you are looking for.
Love to Quilt is wonderful, worth visiting. It's south of town in an interesting open mall area called The Shops at Kingsmill; the location of the shop is hard to find, unfortunately, as it's halfway down the walkway between buildings, parking lots on each END of the walkway.
If you have a vehicle, it is also worth driving 20+ minutes south to Newport News to visit Nancy's Calico Patch on Rt. 60. They are also a Bernina dealer as well as a full quilt store.
www.ncpquilting.com
Good Mexican restaurant almost across the street called Plaza Azteca.
Jan in VA