My sister-in-law knitted 2 gorgeous, lacy scarves for me. I've had a couple of men stop me on the street and ask where I got one in particular, because they wanted to buy one for their wives. Other than that, I haven't received any handmade gifts. Not a crafty bunch, I guess.
I like to give quilts and BBQ sauce. Everyone loves my BBQ sauce, they all think I should produce it commercially. I make gallons and gallons every summer, and if you're good you get some for Christmas.