I like that black lacquer w/ the gold. But what a lot of work.
To me, that cabinet is square enough that you don't notice the colonial feet at first. I think I have even seen some Craftsman furniture that had a bit of colonial flair.
I would take it a little toward Mission or Shaker, in a cherry stain. I'm lazy, so I would pick a drawer pull with a backplate to help cover up if old holes if I can''t find new pulls that are the same centers.
http://www.knobsandhardware.com/cabi...ductItemsImage
[ATTACH=CONFIG]413310[/ATTACH][ATTACH=CONFIG]413312[/ATTACH]
http://www.voorheescraftsman.com/img...20Inspired.jpg
I'd use a cherry or a chestnut color of stain.
[ATTACH=CONFIG]413311[/ATTACH]