Well...I made my decision...I chose the I ♥ My Cat. Mostly because I have too much of that one fabric. I agree that the plain color was a good choice and for the reasons some stated...it doesn't compete with the design. However...that meant buying more fabric and I didn't want to go to the store again. I will post a picture after it is quilted.
Thank you ALL for you opinions! It really helps to hear what you say