Neesie, there is nothing wrong with asking! I didn't see any badly cut charms in the 6 sets I got, but I did get back several of my own. I am not upset... just figure it is pretty confusing to swap for so many people without mistakes!
I think we all are going to get a few that don't quite fit the bill for us. Maybe we should label those seperately if we are sending them back in, if the coordinator is willing to pick them out to send to new people. I wouldn't want to get the same fabrics over again.
I think it should be up to the coordinator to make the rule to re-swap or not to re-swap, as it's more work for her to be sure reswaps go to new people only.
Just my two cents... I will live with it either way and still enjoy the fun!