I was thinking I'd like a scrappy layout, but as I look at your three choices, the last one is calling to me. I love bright colors, and you've chosen some great ones! I, too, toss my scrappies. I already have six bins of scraps, and am now only saving big pieces. I find, that even though I love scrappy quilts, I usually go to my stash and don't use my scraps. I think it's because I want to use different fabrics. If I keep using my scraps, my quilts tend to have the same look.... even though the patterns are different, using the same fabrics over and over tends to get boring for me.