That is too funny.. We have situation like that, but it has to do with a goldendoodle that decided the big leather chair is hers. If a person sits on the chair, she will circle around a couple of times, and then start to voice her opinion that you are sitting on her chair. I decided to turn the tables on her, and let her know I wasn't getting up.. She ended up sitting on the couch, and whining.. I waited a few minutes, and she got up, and started to bark. I thought that she had to go out.. I got up to get her leash, and she ran over to the chair, and sat down.. That meant war.. I wasn't going to let her get away with bullying me off the chair.. I went into the kitchen, and got a treat.. I left it on the other side of the room.. and sat down on the couch, and waited.. She started to whine.. but got up to get it..