I'm sure Annie's carries high quality fabric but it doesn't seem like you are getting a break on the cost of the fabric. Personally, I like to pick my fabric rather than have someone else do it. You do get a pattern but again I like to see if beforehand and decide if I would use it. Plus you have to consider the amount of postage and handling. Unless I was building a stash or did not have places to shop in person, I would pass it up. Is it something you can cancel at any time or are you committed to a certain length of time. I do not belong to this fabric club so perhaps someone will chime in that is a member.