Originally Posted by PatriceJ

when it comes to color or pattern choices, i'd say [just about] "anything goes."
what appeals to one person might not appeal to another ... and vice versa.

when it comes to quality of construction, though, nobody should ever donate a quilt they know is poorly made.
whether or not the recipient will "know the difference" is beside the point.

an inspector should not pass on a quilt/top they can see is poorly constructed.
it is not charity when the donated item is better suited to decorating a landfill.
it is not an act of kindness to dump our rejects on people who are already unfortunate in one way or another.
it is not generous to expect recipients to be grateful for whatever they get.

we should never donate anything we are not confident will survive daily use and frequent washing.
if it isn't good enough for a friend or member of our family, then it isn't good enough for a stranger.