Elisabrat: We all agree we fall of the wagon repeatedly but the general consensus is we really reduce our over all expenditures and that's all to the good. I don't think you have fully addressed yourself to the fact that as Sandy pointed out, red is irresistible therefore it falls in a different category. Remember Mary had just gone through a totally traumatic experience and needed some retail therapy. She literally had her *** in a wringer. All in all I think a .5 demerit is all that Mary has earned. Nancia is usually our legal authority on these matters, maybe she will chime in.