It's a great scrappy. I too struggled with scrappy quilts, as I tended to make very coordinated quilts - then I started making family reunion quilts, which were completely scrappy from the fabric my family sent to make it. My family loves the quilts, and although I may choose a color or group of colors (red/white/blue) I am sometimes challenged to include some of the "klunker" fabrics, but they always turn out beautiful. At least I've loosened up my OCD and perfectionism, which is a good thing. It's made me grow as a quilter as well.