I see I am very late for this post, but Yep---knew Cootie & played it at home. We had one.
Some more:
Mr. Potato Head - the real one where you pushed the plastic pieces into a real potato!!
Yo-Yos
Bikes
Erector Sets (my brother's, but we all used it)
Home made skateboards - no one was making them yet.
All steel Skates with skate keys that clamped on your shoes
45 records & little box players
Jacks (one of my favorites!!)
Marbles (where's my shooter cats eye?)
Baby dolls with strollers & beds
Barbie (but I never got 1 - we couldn't afford it, and I was really too old when she first came out)
Books - I was a voracious reader!