I tried the paper plates in my pantry, but they were too thick for the punch. They are heavier than the ones with the ruffled edge. I did hit on punching index cards--and that DID seem to be about the weight of the precut pieces. Could only get three hexis to a 3x5 card, but will look for bigger ones at the Dollar Store. Really liked the weight and feel of the index cards. Will try them today and report back!