Hmmm..
Not sure.. I get the high loft batting deal, and understand that's not a mistake on their part...
But it looks like there's "sort of" puckering in some of pics you posted. Probably appears that way to me as I am like you, I usually use Warm and Natural or a low loft batting...So I'm used to a "flatter" appearance.
Be interesting to see how a quilt would look with low loft batting.
On a side note, love your quilt...green is my fave color.
Kif