I personally liked the small gridded fabric because it had a different scale, but I agree most of what you started with are lights so you still need more darks. Unless you scattered in the new fabrics in a larger chunks to make the impact you need and did just smaller bits of the lights. Like maybe a snowball block? For me the larger leaf print is too much the same as the one with the lines in it. If it were me I'd pick only one of those and pull out the other. But these fabrics should make a lovely fall quilt. I know what it's like to want to use from your stash and not have to buy much new. Been there! Good luck with your project.