Styrofoam cups, paper plates, pom poms, empty frosting cans, dowel rods, wooden cut outs in assorted shapes, fun foam, felt sheets, sequins, glitter glue, pony beads, Perler beads, empty spools and cones, fabric scraps, magnet sheets, Shrinky Dink sheets, yarn, wired ribbon, pine cones, smooth rocks, toilet paper and or paper towel tubes, small milk or juice cartons, stencils, cookie cutters, sponges, rubber stamps
Print outs of simple instructions for assorted crafts or pictures of projects to get their mind going. My craft dresser includes all of the above and more. It started with a Girl Scout troop I lead for years and has been passed down to the grandkids.