Oh, MacThayer, I am soooooo sorry this happened to one of your quilts--but as a long armer (with cats) myself, I can understand her predicament--and would also have been in tears when having to call you. You are a wonder in understanding her end of the problem; and I do feel she is being as reasonable as she can be with her offer of future free LAing.
Any of the quilts shown are reasonably quick to finish in time for a Christmas gift (at this time) providing you are not snowed under by other Christmas gifts and requests. You just don't have the time to mull and agonize over them like I do when I am trying to select something for someone special.
Please keep us posted on your decision and how this turns out for you. Love and best wishes.