I have made many hexies..Tried all sizes..I prefer the 1 1/2 size..They are easy to handle and yet not too big or small in my opinion..I also use the plastic templates ..They save u lots of money and time in the long run..I only use 3 templates..I take out as I go..I find the paper it's soft and loses it's shape after a few times..Which loses he true shape ..But mainly it is your personal taste..Made a couple different sizes..Look at them for a iittle while .It will click in which u prefer ...