I have over 300 magazines. I hate looking at a magazine with ripped out pages, absolutely detest it. If I did this to any of my magazines, I would recycle the magazine with my trash. I put markers in the pages of the magazines that I love and set them aside. I have no idea what I will do with the others right now. Some of these vintage magazines cost me $1.00 each at antique stores so I am not planning on giving them away.