I like kzimmer's idea -- very masculine. Either fleece on the back or flannel, to keep the back side soft. If he doesn't like it, you are not out a lot of money, but I bet he (and/or his friends when they come over) will like it. Even if it gets used by the dog, or for moving furniture, he will remember who made it for him. Sometimes these things become valuable to the owner later. I would do it.