If you don't mind paper piecing here are links to a few sites with free small patterns. Right now Quilters Newsletter has free (but not for long) PP Christmas Surprise, most of the blocks are 3-4". Make sure you show us what you decide! Good luck!
http://www.yvonnes.dk/free-patchwork...ristmas-small/
http://www.caroldoak.com/free-quilt-patterns.php
http://liljabs.com/holiday-themed/#Rudolph
http://www.quiltersnewsletter.com/is...tmas-Surprises