Thanks everyone for all your replies! I'm going to spend some time looking at all your links. I've kind of avoided thrift store buys even tho they often have the 'old fashioned' version I'm looking for, only bc I don't expect one from there to live very long if it works at all. Maybe I shoud reconsider....
Quiltingcandy, you can come over for waffles anytime you like! I will even get those dollar store or frozen ones for now. Just bring your sewing machine with you. I'll even supply a wip or ufo to keep you busy while we wait on the toaster.
Annaquilts...your explanation is perfect. I'm not a fan of deep pockets...at least in this case.
Geri B...I LOVE your ideas.